Stuck On Replay - Your Review - UNDER THE RADAR OVER THE TOP

Stuck On Replay - Your Review

Dear visitor, welcome to SCOOTERTECHNO.COM. If this is your first visit here, please read the Help. It explains in detail how this page works. To use all features of this page, you should consider registering. Please use the registration form, to register here or read more information about the registration process. If you are already registered, please login here.

Mr Hyper

Professional

Posts: 1,116

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 11:28am

Stuck On Replay - Your Review

HOW DO YOU RATE IT?

A total of 52 Votes have been submitted.

13%

supadupa (7)

13%

very good (7)

25%

good (13)

17%

average (9)

12%

bad (6)

19%

poor (10)

Today there will be the worldwide internet presentation of the "SOR"-radio edit with its video.
After having listened to the radio edit/watched the video, you can write a review on the song here.

Go to the top of the page

scooterdan

Trainee

Posts: 107

Location: Adelaide, SA

Occupation: printer

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:09pm

Currently being uploaded i believe....half is up!!

Go to the top of the page

Mr Hyper

Professional

Posts: 1,116

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:19pm

Well, I'm a bit disappointed. The video is still the old version with a few hockey scenes, but the shuffle scenes don't really fit to the hockey scenes. A brandnew hockey video would have been better.
The radio edit itself is disappointing because there are no real changes in comparison to the album version - still the old "cool" hpv instead of Kamala's sweet voice, still no C-Part, still only a length of 3:10. The album version could have been turned into something really bomby with some obvious changes (Kamala, C-Part). But they put only a few fresh effects into the song and missed to improve it really.
With only such small changes "Where the beats..." would have been the better choice for a single, because an almost-not-changed version of "WTB..." is better and more "earwormy" than this almost-not-changed version of "SOR".
Don't you misunderstand me: The song is still good, especially the catchy HP shouts ("He say, she say..."), but they missed the chance to turn into something very good or supadupa.
My chart tip for Germany: # 11-16, but not T10.

Go to the top of the page

Eyeball_Paul

Trainee

Posts: 129

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:26pm

what a painful experience...

single version is almost the same as album version, except some sounds are a little bit polished and improved...it seems they've become so lazy that they even can't produce a proper single version...TSAMH Radio Edit was 1st proof and now here's the second...
also, as i expected the video would be the old one from the preview + some random hockey footage....watched it once and it's more then enough for me...
I hoped that P.U.C.K. would be a great trance instrumental, but with this kind of laziness i seriously doubt it...

Go to the top of the page

Big J

Unregistered

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:31pm

Aaa..., thumbs down so far :-(

Go to the top of the page

Mr Hyper

Professional

Posts: 1,116

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:41pm

But producing an improved single version wouldn't have been so difficult- they had time since December and with a length of 3:10 it would have been no problem to put a C-Part into the song. And replacing the male hpv with a female Kamala hpv wouldn't have been a big problem either - they made it with I'm lonley so why not with this song?

Go to the top of the page

fanatik_scooter

Sage

Posts: 4,618

Location: Kronstadt, Romania

Occupation: Student

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:49pm

Quoted from "Mr Hyper"

Well, I'm a bit disappointed. The video is still the old version with a few hockey scenes, but the shuffle scenes don't really fit to the hockey scenes. A brandnew hockey video would have been better.
The radio edit itself is disappointing because there are no real changes in comparison to the album version - still the old "cool" hpv instead of Kamala's sweet voice, still no C-Part, still only a length of 3:10. The album version could have been turned into something really bomby with some obvious changes (Kamala, C-Part). But they put only a few fresh effects into the song and missed to improve it really.
With only such small changes "Where the beats..." would have been the better choice for a single, because an almost-not-changed version of "WTB..." is better and more "earwormy" than this almost-not-changed version of "SOR".
Don't you misunderstand me: The song is still good, especially the catchy HP shouts ("He say, she say..."), but they missed the chance to turn into something very good or supadupa.
My chart tip for Germany: # 11-16, but not T10.

nothing more to add. The only good thing is Giedre

I hope Ed won't shoot me LOL

All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.

Go to the top of the page

Scooterworld

a.k.a. Edgar ® ------------ "When I say E, you say Z"

Posts: 18,789

Location: The Netherlands

Occupation: Building designer & CAD-drawer :)

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:52pm

Quoted from "fanatik_scooter"

nothing more to add. The only good thing is Giedre I hope Ed won't shoot me LOL

I won't shoot you

Because of the many Giedre parts it's my favourite video

.... the rest is OK, I like the video, not bad......but no match to Ti Sento ofcourse, but I can't complain

H.P.'s "The Voice" - "The Myth" > He stands out all above the rest, blonder than the best!

Go to the top of the page

Mr Hyper

Professional

Posts: 1,116

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:52pm

Who or what is Giedre? :?:

If you mention "Ti sento" - this song with its video was something fresh (even in spite of the fact that it is inspired by Technoboy in a massive way

) - there were electro/techno effects that were untypical for Scooter (especially within the C-part), the autotune effect was great in that song, the chorus style and its singer were also something new - but everything was really fitting and gave a "round" song. And when watching the video I had the feeling I was watching a movie premiere in a luxuriuos cinema.

Go to the top of the page

Shadow3k

Professional

Posts: 1,109

Location: far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far away!

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:54pm

As I said...don't expect too much

Scooter - Eine Band die sich immer verändert, aber trotzdem immer gleich bleibt!

Go to the top of the page

Scooterworld

a.k.a. Edgar ® ------------ "When I say E, you say Z"

Posts: 18,789

Location: The Netherlands

Occupation: Building designer & CAD-drawer :)

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:55pm

Quoted from "Mr Hyper"

Who or what is Giedre?

The female dancer that is showed quite often in the video, Rick looks at her bottom etc

She was also dancer on the JAOTW tour

H.P.'s "The Voice" - "The Myth" > He stands out all above the rest, blonder than the best!

Go to the top of the page

bigswano

Unregistered

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:55pm

kind of disappointing.

I mean, the album version's sort of a guilty pleasure for me, but I was hoping that they would have made some more meaningful changes for the single. Basically the altered vocals and the synth backing to the verses are the only things they've done to this track. I was hoping for a c-part and perhaps a new synth melody after the vocals to replace the obviously ripped melody from a kay a (ehm mix). All the changes made have been for the better, but those changes are only very slight. As always I'll be interested in hearing the b-side, extended and club mixes of this single, but it's disappointing that the general public will only get to hear this mediocre radio edit.

The video's a bit forgettable too, but I like the man love between Rick and Michael.

Go to the top of the page

fanatik_scooter

Sage

Posts: 4,618

Location: Kronstadt, Romania

Occupation: Student

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 12:58pm

and she is damn pretty!! When i saw her in Budapest 2 m away from me ( saw her when they left with the car...so i was very close to her) I said "holly shi!, Ed has good tastes when it comes about womans"

All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.

Go to the top of the page

Mr Hyper

Professional

Posts: 1,116

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 1:04pm

"Giedre" is a strange name to German ears - it sounds more like a name for a Dutch man, I would have never thought that there is a beautiful woman behind this name

Go to the top of the page

Scooterworld

a.k.a. Edgar ® ------------ "When I say E, you say Z"

Posts: 18,789

Location: The Netherlands

Occupation: Building designer & CAD-drawer :)

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 1:07pm

Quoted from "fanatik_scooter"

and she is damn pretty!! When i saw her in Budapest 2 m away from me ( saw her when they left with the car...so i was very close to her) I said "holly shi!, Ed has good tastes when it comes about womans"

I'm glad you like her too

.... she's indeed damn pretty :thumbup:

H.P.'s "The Voice" - "The Myth" > He stands out all above the rest, blonder than the best!

Go to the top of the page

Almanac

Junglist Soldier

Posts: 1,531

Location: All over the world

Occupation: DJ

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 1:34pm

Well it is certainly better than the album version, and I like it, not my favorite, but it's good! The video is great!

LOL at :30 seconds, you clearly see a guy mouthing "F@CK!"

Oh, and she is REALLY pretty. I hope she's at the tour, maybe I can get a picture with her

www.facebook.com/mraudity

Go to the top of the page

aganim

tremble with terror

Posts: 2,854

Location: Leer (GERMANY)

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 1:52pm

average

Go to the top of the page

Imre -SP-

aka. DJ Flatline

Posts: 5,802

Location: Budapest / Hungary

Occupation: owner of Scootertechno Hungary

Thursday, February 25th 2010, 2:05pm

Don't worry, there will be some ppl who will say OMG BEST VIDEO EVER SCOOTER R0XX0RZ FUKKEN YEAH!!!!!1111ONE

Anyway, it's nothing special. It's OK for the IIHF theme, but the two chicks and the shufflers just don't fit in :/ And poor Rick & Michael are out of focus again...
However, HUGE THUMB UP for showing a LOT of Hungarians

High five goes to the director!