You are not logged in.

41

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:35pm

Quoted from ""Sheffieldsfan""

that appears a little close-minded to me. sorry.

I think it can't be coincidence that after every 4 years a member says: "Oh, I don't like what I'm doing. I want to be on my own again"


Exactly, that's very narrow-minded thinking, it seems like he want to convince himself that Jay left on his own because he doesn't want to admit that it's all in a simple contract.

Anonymous

Unregistered

42

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:37pm

Quoted from ""wholaughsnow""

Quoted from ""geeteeage""

Jay didnt kill scooter, he RISED !


yeah this is why success of Scooter was getting down from year to year from single to single, album to album since some years...
2003 was the only good year with him, after it Scooter only fallen deeper and deeper until today. I don't want say that he was the only reason but he couldn't wake up Scooter and push them with his influence like Axel did after Ferris.

but the concerts gettin bigger and bigger.how comes?

43

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:40pm

Consider this..
What was Ferris before Scooter?
What was Axel before Scooter?
What was Jay before Scooter?


Not much.
They wanted to have a solo career so they could try out how they would manage without Scooter, or to try and do entirely the kind of stuff they want to. None of them were that famous before Scooter. Perhaps they all had done something before, I don't know that well, but I for example had never heard of Jay Frog before I saw he was a Scooter member.

Now it's his time to create his own reputation, or should we say more reputation, as his Scooter reputation is excellent, as that's what he wants to do. 8)
:rolleyes: This is a signature.

ddestructor

Intermediate

Posts: 399

Location: The Big B

  • Send private message

44

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:42pm

MAYBE, he leave the band in fact of the constant criticism at its person and his influence to Scooter-music from some fans here?
So, that he said "F**k you all, I'm away!" :?
Don't have to be beautiful...but it helps

45

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:43pm

Quoted from ""ddestructor""

Maybe, he leave the band in fact of the constant criticism at its person and his influence to Scooter-music from some fans here?
So, that he said "F**k you all, I'm away!" :?


That's post of a year. :lol: :lol: :lol:

46

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:46pm

Quoted from ""Butcher""

Quoted from ""ddestructor""

Maybe, he leave the band in fact of the constant criticism at its person and his influence to Scooter-music from some fans here?
So, that he said "F**k you all, I'm away!" :?


That's post of a year. :lol: :lol: :lol:


Come on. He tells the truth. Jay couldn't handle pressure which S.O.S. topic made :lol:

I'm more into that 4 years system. It already happened 3rd time :roll:
Waiting for albums from Way Out West, Sasha, Second Sun, Airwave, BT, Quivver, Pendulum, Solarstone, Röyksopp and Massive Attack


ddestructor

Intermediate

Posts: 399

Location: The Big B

  • Send private message

47

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:50pm

Quoted from ""Butcher""

Quoted from ""ddestructor""

Maybe, he leave the band in fact of the constant criticism at its person and his influence to Scooter-music from some fans here?
So, that he said "F**k you all, I'm away!" :?


That's post of a year. :lol: :lol: :lol:

So, why not? It COULD be ONE possibility!
Don't have to be beautiful...but it helps

pjad_uk

Master

Posts: 1,828

Location: Bristol, UK

Occupation: Student @ The University of Bristol, UK

  • Send private message

48

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:54pm

Quoted from ""ddestructor""

Quoted from ""Butcher""

Quoted from ""ddestructor""

Maybe, he leave the band in fact of the constant criticism at its person and his influence to Scooter-music from some fans here?
So, that he said "F**k you all, I'm away!" :?


That's post of a year. :lol: :lol: :lol:

So, why not? It COULD be ONE possibility!


I doubt it. I know Jay received a lot of criticism but in general the criticism was for the whole band. The band has to share resposiblity collectively for the things they do and music they produce.
"In the pressure of the situation, I won't let my tongue get tied
A silent voice in the congregation, I refuse to live a lie"
Angelic - Can't Keep Me Silent

49

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:58pm

Quoted from ""Butcher""

Exactly, that's very narrow-minded thinking, it seems like he want to convince himself that Jay left on his own because he doesn't want to admit that it's all in a simple contract.

Well, in that case you are very wrong. I can easily accept it being just a contract, but I just don't think it is. In case it is, then everyone can please shut up and stop complaining, they knew perfectly well what they did when they signed the contract, it was their own choice entirely, too.

I don't see any benefit in such contract, and I'm fairly sure they know such thing wouldn't work three times in a row without someone noticing it. :lol:
:rolleyes: This is a signature.

Posts: 2,162

Location: Flekkefjord, Norwegen

Occupation: Schueler

  • Send private message

50

Monday, August 14th 2006, 8:59pm

Quoted from ""pjad_uk""

Quoted from ""ddestructor""

Quoted from ""Butcher""

Quoted from ""ddestructor""

Maybe, he leave the band in fact of the constant criticism at its person and his influence to Scooter-music from some fans here?
So, that he said "F**k you all, I'm away!" :?


That's post of a year. :lol: :lol: :lol:

So, why not? It COULD be ONE possibility!


I doubt it. I know Jay received a lot of criticism but in general the criticism was for the whole band. The band has to share resposiblity collectively for the things they do and music they produce.


No pjad, it surely was you who scared Jay away :wink:

51

Monday, August 14th 2006, 9:01pm

Hm...you don't see the benefit?Is that possible?H.P. & Rick want to ensure that new ideas evolve in the band, that the music doesn't get too boring and repetitive and to always invent some changes to their style.

Nobody noticing?It's just so obvious.Who could notice sth. like that, these are private things, not public operations. :lol: Perhaps nothing is on a paper, although I claim it is, but it's just an arrangement of the band members.Do you think that forum members will notice sth. like that? :lol: It's between Scooter, Thele and probably some other Kontor guys, I don't know, it's not even especially important.

52

Monday, August 14th 2006, 9:02pm

Quoted from ""Sheffieldsfan""

Quoted from ""pjad_uk""



I doubt it. I know Jay received a lot of criticism but in general the criticism was for the whole band. The band has to share resposiblity collectively for the things they do and music they produce.


No pjad, it surely was you who scared Jay away :wink:


No. it was S.O.S. topic!!!!eleveneleven
Waiting for albums from Way Out West, Sasha, Second Sun, Airwave, BT, Quivver, Pendulum, Solarstone, Röyksopp and Massive Attack


Posts: 2,162

Location: Flekkefjord, Norwegen

Occupation: Schueler

  • Send private message

53

Monday, August 14th 2006, 9:07pm

Quoted from ""Butcher""

Hm...you don't see the benefit?Is that possible?H.P. & Rick want to ensure that new ideas evolve in the band, that the music doesn't get too boring and repetitive and to always invent some changes to their style.

Nobody noticing?It's just so obvious.Who could notice sth. like that, these are private things, not public operations. :lol: Perhaps nothing is on a paper, although I claim it is, but it's just an arrangement of the band members.Do you think that forum members will notice sth. like that? :lol: It's between Scooter, Thele and probably some other Kontor guys, I don't know, it's not even especially important.


Yu read my thoughts. seriously

RAY SHULTZ

Beginner

Posts: 15

Location: Ukraine,Odessa (can you find it on the map ?)

  • Send private message

54

Monday, August 14th 2006, 9:32pm

I totally agree with Butcher, and i think it became obvious 4 years ago when Axel left the band. We can't claim something like "It was a very bad idea" or scream happily "Oh, Jay has left the band...finally...ha-ha-ha" just because it happen. We have to wait for the new songs

55

Monday, August 14th 2006, 9:47pm

i agree with some of the people in here. i really think that he was kicked like the 2 before. same way they did it before to the others. i really like scooter. but now i think the only think they care for is the money.

everytime they kicked the 3. member. they produce as well. so why wasn't jay good enough, why wasn't axel good enough or ferris?
if rick and hp are good enough why do they need a new fresh member every 4 years to get new ideas and influences? that shows to me that they're not good enough to do it on there own. i'm sorry to say that. but they don't need another member if they are really good.

i'm really dissapointment to see that they don't care for their band just for there money.

maybe it will be better, maybe it won't.
maybe they should change hp or rick, maybe they will get fresh and new ideas and influences then.


do they really think that people believes the topic with the soloprojects? every band says that, if one of the member has to leave the band. i don't believe it till the day i talk to jay and he tells me that he wanted to do more soloprojects.

like someone said before, rick, jay and hp = scooter

i don't want to acclimate with a new member every 4 years!

Anonymous

Unregistered

56

Monday, August 14th 2006, 9:57pm

we all dont know why they left the band.
the only thing what is clear that this is a hard job.producing travelling and Djing(Jay)
So maybe hes just burned out.i heard that really often and in other examples from known stars you can see that.

Posts: 2,162

Location: Flekkefjord, Norwegen

Occupation: Schueler

  • Send private message

57

Monday, August 14th 2006, 10:01pm

right, being a star is no peace of cake/ Zuckerschlecken....officially Axel was quite exhausted as well

Dave From Sheffield

Volvo. A car you can believe in.

Posts: 9,367

Location: Finland

  • Send private message

58

Monday, August 14th 2006, 10:38pm

This is what i get for defending the present Scooter. :lol: :roll: :P
Oh well, some people just won't understand. Instead if even trying they just call names and talk other shit. How pathetic is that... :wink:
http://www.freewebs.com/scooterdave
-the only and official finnish Scooter fansite incl. the biggest Scooter-collection in Finland-

pjad_uk

Master

Posts: 1,828

Location: Bristol, UK

Occupation: Student @ The University of Bristol, UK

  • Send private message

59

Monday, August 14th 2006, 10:47pm

Quoted from ""Dave From Sheffield""

This is what i get for defending the present Scooter. :lol: :roll: :P
Oh well, some people just won't understand. Instead if even trying they just call names and talk other S##t. How pathetic is that... :wink:


Pardon, Dave? Did you say something?
"In the pressure of the situation, I won't let my tongue get tied
A silent voice in the congregation, I refuse to live a lie"
Angelic - Can't Keep Me Silent